We use cookies to optimize your experience, analyze traffic, and personalize ads. Please choose whether you accept our use of non-essential cookies. Read More
Climate - It's more than weather
Climate has been changing since the earth began. From hot, to cold, wet to dry but currently the big worry is that we humans are causing rapid warming due to our activities, i.e. anthropocentric change. It’s one big aspect of our environment but not the only aspect.
The world went through the Medieval Warm Period (MWP) in roughly 800 to 1300 AD (sort of the middle ages period in Europe). Agriculture boomed, times were prosperous. Temperatures were 1 to 2 degrees above average, possibly warmer then now. This was followed by the Little Ice Age, from early 14th century through the mid-19th century or a bit latter. Neither of these changes can be attributed to human activity.
Our present concern about the world becoming warmer starts with a baseline late in the Little Ice Age which is seldom mentioned and doesn’t seem to have warmed to the MWP temperatures.
Of course this is all argued about, how extensive the periods were, the inaccuracies of temperature estimates (no we don’t have satellite data of those time), but the basic periods or temperature changes are not disputed.
It generates arguments on both sides with doomsday predictions from those saying its all down to us mainly due to our energy use. The other side says no it’s natural to go through changes and we can do little to stop this.
The Emergency?
Some of the world and the UK have gone gung-ho for climate change as an emergency and the causative effects proposed due to human produced carbon dioxide, CO2 and other greenhouse gases.
The proposals are for reductions, often drastic reductions, in energy use among other things from carbon bearing sources such as coal, oil and gas to a carbon net-zero target. Reductions, if not elimination, of all our other CO2 producing activities also being demanded.
The aim is a carbon neutral budget. We are told this is to save the planet as it’s an emergency, sort of nothing else matters.
Yes there is scientific evidence that the world is warming. Warming may be both naturally due to very long term periodic change on the earths axis tilt which influences solar gain and the sun’s changing brightness levels. Maybe also on our and other nearby planets elliptical orbit around the sun interacting.
The earths elliptical orbit, the wobbles, the axis shift all have different periodicities. The Serbian scientist Milankovitch hypothesized the confluence of the different movements would act as a trigger for the glaciation periods. It’s disputed whether the Milankovitch cycles would be great enough to cause any rapid change.
So the CO2 issue
Climate change is projected as real, as a scientifically proven fact caused by anthropocentric carbon emissions. It does depend on extrapolations and assumptions that the worlds “climate sensitivity” is high to levels of CO2 so small changes in CO2 will cause large changes in temperature.
Some scientists instead find “climate sensitivity” is low so CO2 changes may be less or insignificant. The modelling also assumes the world is a steady state one with near constant temperatures and any deviation is unusual. Others suggest the world is a chaotic entity and deviations from steady is to be expected.
Certainly evidence does exists that our current situation is in the normal expected range of temperature as seen over thousands of years, of Greenland ice cover, of land and sea temperature. Might even be in the expected range over just a few hundreds of years, OK, just not in the 20 to 80 year span.
CO2 may not be as important as some hypothesis suggest, so Climate Change may not be the Emergency or maybe it is. This does not mean the other environmental problems are not at emergency levels.
All controversial, but most research funding is toward emphasizing the catastrophic side as part of a precautionary approach. The “end of the world is coming” approach to argument. So, lets temporarily leave climate change aside to consider other aspects of environment.
But quick before leaving, What if the world warming doesn’t stop? All our trillions of dollars, pounds, euros is being spent on reducing CO2, little is being spent and little preparation being made for survival in a much warmer chaotic world. Maybe this needs attention.
Habitat Loss
Economics and ecology do come in. People seem to endeavour for a standard of living above the just surviving poverty level. Questions in most populations find almost everyone would like to have a standard of living just a little bit better.
Migration, immigration is partly, maybe mainly, driven by this desire to improve standards of living. Employment has similar driving forces. People work, do things, to survive. This all uses materials and energy. These are our pollutants, the factors degrading the world we live on but also the main aspect of our standard of living.

Curtailing uses of materials and energy to zero isn’t an option for survival, so the question must be to what level of use do we accept. Do we want equilibrium levels of use? This might put us surviving maybe as our ancestors did 4-5,000 years ago, oops no probably 20,000+ years ago or more. Humans have been changing the environment for at least that long.
The thoughts and proposals come down to a change in quality of life, of lifestyle, with lots of technological fixes thrown in. The average carbon footprint of a UK resident is roughly 9.5 tonnes per year, about middle ranking, but deemed too high. If we include our exported carbon production, that produced by importing manufactured goods and food from industries we have shut down locally, we are maybe at 14 tonnes per year or more.
Lifestyle changes
Lots of questions, lots of choices
Realistically as individuals we want a standard of living about as we have now, maybe just a little better or maybe we would be willing to go down slightly. What do we want for the other person?
Do we make these lifestyle changes in an egalitarian manor or exempt the few, the well off, the politically connected, an ethnic minority, religious groups?
Travel
Should the entertainers, international athletes, politicians, business executives be allowed to drive or fly more than the average person? For instance should we still have international sport, like football, on TV or should it even be allowed at all in a environmentally concerned state? Players frequently travel the world as do fans, presenters, support staff can they be exempt from climate change requirements? Do we simply, put prices up, up again to stop the average person so they do the savings of the climate while the others feel good?
Food
Food is shipped around the world, its carbon footprint can be high but sometimes lower than locally produced. Do carbon taxes kick in to change the diet of the majority? Imported fruit, even vegetables make up a portion of the British diet some of which are environmentally damaging in the growing countries. Do we ban oranges, avocados, most nuts, bananas, etc. as imported from a distance, potentially environmentally damaging?
Do we voluntarily chose to eat only in season, locally produced food produced with low energy input? Do we subsidize the farmers no longer supplying us? Do we accept that some people may simply starve to death?
The UK is a bit more efficient, produce less CO2, in food production than many poorer countries. Should we prohibit food imports from less efficient produces. Should our food production be reduced to adopt rewilding policies?
Worldwide total carbon budget for all food is about 17 percent of the total budget, somewhat less than domestic houses or cars. Some countries which used to be self sustaining in food now have to import partly due to habitat loss, partly population gain. Should importing be stopped.
Should society insist that everyone must simply be very poor? My personal prejudice is not to like force, dictation, or being coerced, but to make my own decisions. Maybe this is considered unreasonable as many seem to want to micro manage and dictate.
Individual vs Collective
Do we make unalterable choices for others saying what they can’t have or must have?
Do we dictate how food is produced, say no pesticides and accept that 20 to 30 percent of production can go to waste, let people starve with that lower output?
Do we voluntarily chose to eat only in season, locally produced food produced with low energy input? Do we subsidize the farmers no longer supplying us?
Do we demand maximum use of Genetical Modified Crops, GMO’s, as they can be produced with less CO2 production. Do we push for veganism to save animal production of CO2 and methane (do humans eating more plant material produce more gas?). For the same vegetable mater input how do humans verses cows compare on gas production?
Do we allow people to have choices or instead do we want complete control by authorities?
Many, most, poorer countries as they become more prosperous have increases in food and particularly meat consumption. OK, a healthy diet is desirable but what is that, who decides, how is it put forward?

Cook your own food of course, just consider a gas oven uses half the energy of an electric oven while a microwave uses less again. Then think about this: the most energy efficient is mass produced and prepared food served in a communal canteen. Where is the line drawn? Do we all have to eat MacDonalds or school cantean?
Should only the well off, the rich, the politically correct and connected have freedom? Chose the food they eat, the travel they do, the house they live in?
All motorized transport, even electric cars, have a carbon footprint roughly the same as heating in domestic housing. Cut both by equal amounts, transport by more, do it by price so the well off aren’t affected much? Just cut private car use so personal choice is limited for the majority?
Loss of habitat is important. The UK main uses of land are 63 percent for agriculture, 34.7 percent for natural area, 6 percent is built on in some fashion. Habitats are everywhere, even in cities, just different. It’s a value judgment on importance if it comes to preserving.
The UK Committee on Climate Change wants to reduce farmland by 25 percent converting it into a mix of natural and biofuel production land. This goes along with removing gas central heating so wood can be burnt and the not so well off can be just a bit colder.
Burning wood of course releases the carbon that was absorbed in growth so short cycling it. Better to make high quality furniture or use in buildings which last hundreds of years not short cycle products if concerned about CO2. What to do with mature trees, mature vegetation of any sort? Nearly any use releases its captured carbon.
Lifestyles
These are just tiny examples of lifestyle changes which can easily produce major reductions in living standards for many as being suggested by the environmental lobby. Of course there is a completely different way of looking at and solving the environmental, the climate change emergency. Population.
Looking for more information on lifestyles, on how countries compare? Numbeo is the world’s largest cost of living database. It is a crowd-sourced global listing of quality of life information including housing indicators, perceived crime rates, and quality of healthcare, among many other statistics. Or try the OECD Better Life Index which can give some general pointers to how the world lives.
Daniel Kahneman, the Nobel prize winning economist, talked on ‘noisy’ human judgements on BBC Radio 4, and has a book on unreliable human decision making which is relevant here. The same analysis maybe should also be applied to scientific views on climate change, on lifestyle choices even on Covid-19 lockdowns and imposed constraints.
The noise in the decision making is a spread of conclusions that will exist even with exactly the same starting data, even with experts analysing. What ecology tells us is a more diverse system is more stable against a change in environment than a highly specialized one. Sort of “don’t put all your eggs in one basket”. This can mitigate some of the noise.
The “experts” don’t seem to talk publicly about any possible downsides to concentrating on CO2 reduction. Little mention of possible reduction in standards of living, how it might affect predominately the less well off to middle income families, nor on world wide shifts in manufacturing, power, political influence. Some analysis of these consequences can be found in research publications by the U.S. Energy Information Administration, International Energy Outlook 2020.
With climate change the “experts” want to put all efforts into greenhouse gas reduction. A very specialized approach to the environment, to economics, to social structure. This could well have some undesired social and economic consequences and maybe not help the environment much if change isn’t totally down to anthropogenic CO2 production.
Questions
Is the living standard wanted for everyone that of the many environmental activists who travel the world multiple times a year, have a large house, use resources at the top few percent level? Is the standard that of the subsistence farmer in a poor country having access to electricity a few hours per week, or something in-between?
Disparity of incomes, of standards of living
Shrinking the range down is on many agendas, but is it just the top few percent they want lowered or top 30 percent, the bottom few percent going up or the bottom 30 percent up? Is it compared worldwide or only developed world? These questions are often skirted over by the enthusiasts, not being answered while being crucial.
Just as a simplistic example, take a low earning British, American or European person and their idea of low consumption is still likely to be more than that of half the worlds population. How do we fit that into the Eco Warier agenda or the world population wanting just a bit better standard of living?
Solution
I think there is a solution, just one seldom talked about or even mentioned. A solution which should be getting the attention now which instead is going to Climate Change, the Climate Change Emergency. But the solution is politically to hot to handle. None of the NGO’s, the charity or political environmental groups will mention it, many scientists won’t say it, governments certainly will not. The world needs a lower total population.
The 26th UN Climate Change Conference (COP26) hosted in Glasgow, UK, 1-12 November 2021 should have had population on their agenda, it didn’t. The COP meetings could be the place to start the dialogue on how to sensibly reduce rate of growth and how to deal with the resultant ageing population. It won’t, it’s seen as racist.
We need to find ways to have population numbers not seen as racist, but as the environmental emergency. The need is to reduce population in a reasonable, acceptable fashion. OK, a tall order.
Historically
For thousand of years world population is thought to have run about 15 million people at most. Start of modern farming and people moving into settled communities it went up to about 300 million by AD 0. Early 19th century it was 1 billion. With the industrial revolution, improved sanitation and modern medicine it was reaching 2 billion in the 1930s and really taking off the mid 1970’s having 4 billion and now over 8 billion headed to 9.7 billion by 2050.
To deny population growth as the reason behind our environmental emergency seems irrational.
Poorer countries have lower carbon footprints than richer ones due to lower standards of living. If warming is the result of anthropogenic CO2 and the climate change time bomb then rationally it would seem governments, environmental groups, NGOs must do everything in their power to prevent poorer countries from improving their lives and start with that right now. Just that no-one wants this and it isn’t a solution.
The results of this population growth along with inequalities of living conditions is the real time bomb, not climate change. Climate change may be a partial result of population growth and economic prosperity releasing more CO2, OK, but don’t try and treat symptoms but look to the cause.
In the UK and many other countries we have a standard of living which is sought after by more than half of the worlds population. Even in our countries few people want to take a substantial reduction in lifestyle. Do you?
A few countries have had a reduction in population. The rate of world population growth is slowing but still expected to reach 10 billion by the 2050’s. Growth rate peaked in the 1970’s and the rate of growth is projected to continue downward to at least the 2100’s but it is still growth.
Poorer countries have lower carbon footprints than richer ones. If warming is the result of anthropogenic CO2 and the climate change time bomb then rationally it would seem governments, environmental groups, NGOs must do everything in their power to prevent poorer countries from improving their lives and start acting that way right now. Just that no-one wants this and it isn’t a solution.
The results of this population growth along with inequalities of living conditions is the real time bomb, not climate change. Climate change may be a partial result of population growth OK, but don’t try and treat symptoms but look to the cause. In the UK and many other countries we have a standard of living which is sought after by more than half of the worlds population. Even in our countries few people want to take a substantial reduction in lifestyle. Do you?
Yes a few countries have had a reduction in population. The rate of world population growth is slowing but still expected to reach 10 billion by the 2050’s. Growth rate peaked in the 1970’s and the rate of growth is projected to continue downward to at least the 2100’s but it is still growth.
Can we cope with increasing population?
Can the environmental, the climate emergency cope with this continued growth or even today’s figure if, say, 2 billion or even 1 billion people want to increase their standards of living up to half or a quarter of ours? Or do we reduce our standard of living to that of a very poor country?
Technological fixes certainly can do a bit. Food production can increase with genetic manipulation; more energy can come from renewables; people can live in tighter spaces, higher densities; more efficiency can be gleaned from products from cars, dishwashers, TVs, computers, etc. Lifestyles can change downward a bit.
Realistically any major downward standard of living change is not going to be politically acceptable. Think of the Yellow Vest movement in France, the union strikes over pay, the clashes in Venezuela, fuel price protests in Iran. Even very well off don’t want less, think of the train drivers of junior doctors in the UK.
Even trying to increase efficiency has problems such as the UK’s older housing stock and limited take up of insulation upgrades. Often those older houses can’t be improved due to type of construction so knock them down (huge carbon footprint) to rebuild?
The UK and even Europe’s green policies are in reality insignificant on a global scale, they are “green wash” just as the demands by XR or a certain young woman are. The idea that the UK can motivate the world by banning sales of carbon fuelled new cars, or building more subsidized wind farms, is wishful thinking which doesn’t tackle the underlying issue of population.
If we really wanted to show real courage and the right way to limit climate change, the environmental emergency we would increase birth control measures, stop all IVF, set child benefits to maximum of one child and start the global dialogues with religious leaders, politicians, internet influencers on how to humanly bring population levels and growth down. More realistically we could at least start the dialogue.
We could be having open dialogues on coping with ageing populations, on social expectations of families of no more than one child. Extinction Rebellion would be protesting outside religious buildings, fertility clinics, social services and cultural centres which support big families. COP meetings would be a springboard to bring population numbers to the forefront. I don’t expect it to happen.
The UK could have a bit of long term and important impact on the environmental Global Emergency if it started the discussions on population. Modern society expects instant gratification, instant results. This, hopefully, doesn’t happen with population reduction but shouldn’t happen with the economy or standards of living either. Socially it just wouldn’t work.
Our Zero Carbon initiative may well be disastrous for our economy. It can easily increase inequalities by driving costs of energy intensive activity and goods higher. We do live in a global world and economy so even though small we do have to compete, the world is unlikely to offer us a free ride because we aim for net zero.
Many of the ideas behind climate change activist may be good, but with an agenda often trying to drive them too soon, too far. The science and technology, the industrial processes for many of these ideas simply isn’t ready yet and may not be for years. By jumping too quick, pushing for instant change can lead to the wrong choices being made. Think of the push for diesel cars and now backtracking on them. The biofuels and food issues. Wood burning power plants and deforestation to fuel them.
Instant isn’t going to keep us going.