So just some maybe wild ideas

Of course preventing anyone from ever getting near anyone else is going to cut transmission of viruses. It’s just a mechanism which would destroy economies and society. Our immune system works reasonably well but is never perfect wither activated by a vaccine or prior exposure.

Ventilation or being outdoors is diluting the concentration of viruses. It’s rather like increasing the distance between people in the social isolation scenario. Both are effectively reducing the concentration of virus in an exposure. Besides this there can also be systems that actually inactivates viruses not just moving them about or preventing people being near potentially infective areas.

There can even be methods which would stop both the covid-19 virus, other viruses and pathogens plus exposure to other airborne pollution.

Devices, machines, things – ways to physically get rid of virus

What I think would help is to bring more ways of fighting coronaviruses and their infections under control is for a small interdisciplinary team to research and design germicidal products or even product ranges which would be inexpensive, easily mass produced and known to work maybe even certified to work.

This isn’t where we go at the moment, it doesn’t seem to get the research funding. Maybe its simply more profitable to research treatments. Yes, incredibly important, but only one aspect of handling disease.

We also have the Stay Healthy advocates but again only one aspect. Nutrition and exercise along with avoiding toxins have a big part in staying healthy. Look at the diet industry, the gym and physical activity advocates. The avoid micro plastics, avoid chemicals, avoid exposure to … brigade.

The kill the pathogens seems come down to various business endeavours often rather hidden away. Yes, just another approach

Potential Products:

Germicidal UV-C

Germicidal UV-C maybe it’s put aside as it was mentioned by Trump. OK Trump didn’t get it right and it is used and use is expanding but could be used much more and maybe to better effect. UV-C with a wavelength from 100 to 280 nanometers is effective, particularly around 254 nm but this has disadvantages used directly; it also damages us, other animals, some plastics, some other materials.


Why not simply contain it in some enclosure with air circulating past and not allowing the light to escape or use it when people aren’t present? OK, this is done, just not inexpensively. It’s also an area with products of such low power they do little.


Why not simply contain it in some enclosure with air circulating past and not allowing the light to escape or use it when people aren’t present? OK, this is done, just not inexpensively. It’s also an area with products of such low power they do little.


A French firm Shark Robotics (shark-robotics) looks to produce a nifty set of devices some using Boston Dynamics robots to move high intensity UVC lights around unoccupied rooms or buildings, but expensive. A California firm, R-Zero (rzero.com), has a much simpler system with the germicidal lights in a tube with a fan to move air through but its still expensive at a few thousand dollars. An English company, UVCleanlight, produces nearly affordable devices starting about £150, and other companies produce other products. It should be possible to have something well under £100. Germicidal tubes are sold as inexpensively as a few pounds.


To inactivate virus particles with UV-C it takes both exposure time and intensity. Some products which can be found on Amazon, eBay and the like are so weak it would take hours even if very close to work. Others are not producing UV-C at all so never work. Peak of the germicidal effectiveness curve of 265 nm, is the most lethal wavelength to microorganisms but a spread of wavelengths still works.


Standard inexpensive glass stops most of the desired wavelengths which is one reason some of the cheap products don’t work.


Problem with UV-C is ozone production


Another problem with UV-C is it can interact with oxygen in the air to produce ozone. Generating lamps using clear fused quartz which allows for the transmission of energy at both 185nm and 254nm wavelengths to produce ozone. By filtering out wavelengths around 185 nm with special lamp glass the ozone production is prevented. Ozone itself is germicidal but most of the time we don’t want too much of it though a little seems to be what makes the seaside air seem fresh.


Far UV-C in the 207–222nm wavelength range still destroys viruses and bacteria by disrupting there DNA. Its penetration distance into tissue is very short so doesn’t seem to go as deep enough into cells to cause damage, but as viruses and bacteria are smaller they are susceptible. Far UV is a still in the research phase as generation by LEDs can’t yet be done and other methods are expensive. Something for the future.

Electrostatic precipitation

Another is air purification with electrostatic precipitation. A static charge is induced into aerosols, dust particles, smoke particles by passing air through a high voltage electric field. The charged particles will migrate to a neutral or opposite charge to lose their charge and generally stick to that surface.

These were all the rage in the 1990’s with inexpensive desktop devices and room devices to freshen the air, but fell out of favor as, well, the charged particles ended up precipitating out on the desk as a great dirty patch. What we want is to have an easily cleaned screen in the airflow with the opposite charge to take the precipitation.

Of course this can be combined with UV-C to not only remove to particles which virus and bacteria are attached to but to inactivate them as well. Some try something like this with HEPA filters, but this can add a lot of airflow resistance so needs more powerful fans to move the air. With the electrostatic method the pressure drop could be minimal so it can be very low power with modern electronics for generating the voltage. It’s something which could run continuously to clean.

Small electrostatic devices sell for under 50 pounds but not designed for this purpose. It should be possible to produce inexpensive units, with germicidal UV-C, with easily removed collecting mesh. This would reduce pollution from traffic, pollen, household and pet dust, along with covid and flu viruses.

A potentiality objection can be that high voltage can produce ozone just like UV-C, but controlling the voltage can reduce this and a manganese dioxide-based catalyst can reduce the ozone to oxygen while also helping in removing nitrogen oxides. So a system which can be inexpensive, cheap to run and reduce indoor pollution along with reducing viruses and bacteria seems worth consideration. It just needs to be designed and put together.

Antiseptic

The covid virus evidently is primarily spread by aerosols not infected surfaces, but-nun the-less an antibiotic which can treat surfaces and maybe to a lesser extent airborne virus could be tossed into the mix. Hypochlorous Acid, which seems to be the same as hydroxyl radicals, activated water, and other names by various sales personal.

Its non-toxic to us, endogenous substance in all mammals, non corrosive, is cheap and easily produced on site from water, salt and an acid like vinegar in an electrolysis cell.

It is effective against a broad range of microorganisms including covid viruses. It’s used in oral-maxillofacial clinic situations as a mouth wash to prevent spread of infections, in traumatic surgery to cleans inside wounds but it is also the fog in fogging machines which we might have seen in photographs from China and other far east countries. Probably the fog spray used on our cricket team going to Sri Lanka.

It deactivates viruses within seconds to minutes depending on concentration. It can be used in fogging machines to sterilize outdoor spaces, becomes even more effective used in electrostatic foggers as more than line of sight can be treated.

Mist sprays have been used in our football stadiums to test ventilation. If this was used before and maybe during games it could reduce possible spread of virus, but it’s use could put up the price of tickets to cover costs, maybe up by 0.01 pound. The same could be in any outdoor crowded gathering.

Earlier mentioned that the high voltage on an electrostatic precipitation could produce ozone. Introducing a water spray can reduce the electrical resistance of the dust particles, allowing them to accept the charge more easily. If this was the source of the water spray those theoretical new electrostatic precipitators could helping to control a whole host of illness inducing airborne nasties.